Jury is in: ‘Blacks don’t care about environment!’

By Nevanji Madanhire

Debate rages on social media on whether white people in Zimbabwe generally care more about the environment than their black compatriots, many attributing the difference in approach to a dysfunctional local governmental system while others blame bad attitudes on the part of the indigenous population.

The consensus has been that though the city councils have been lax in waste management, citizens should have a mindset overhaul so as to be abreast with other parts of the globe on environmental care. The white world learned through disasters such as the bubonic plague the danger of not taking care of the environment and are now all the wiser, making environmental care an integral part of their culture.

The debate was sparked by an article by Nevanji Madanhire published recently in the weekly In Conversation with Trevor newsletter which alludes to the difference in approach to the environment by the two demographic groups.

Environmental engineer Simon Bere, who says he is directly involved in environmental issues in Zimbabwe acknowledged the validity of the question saying “it looks like some difference exists” between the two groups.

“Presently, it is hard to blame residents, white or black. Harare City’s solid waste management system has collapsed,” he wrote. “The city collects refuse disposal fees from residents but does not provide regular collection. They do not provide outside temporary bins in cities and towns.”

Janet Chiedza, another contributor to the debate, sought to debunk the racial aspect of the debate. “It does not have anything to do with race, rather upbringing and grooming,” she writes adding, “It’s the values we teach our children about anything including the environment that moulds and shapes them for life. Charity begins at home and you don’t need to be white or black to instill a culture that can make a difference.”

According to Lois Chingandu, Director External Relations at Frontline AIDS, the buck stops with the local government but citizens also have to hold the city fathers to account.

“Ultimately any rubbish needs to be collected and taken to dumping sites,” she wrote. “People put [waste] on the roadside with the hope that City councillors, paid huge salaries, will do their job, but they still don’t.”

She argues residents should hold the local authorities to account.

“It’s madness that none is holding the City to account for the rates and waste collection money they charge yet never deliver on any services. All they needed was to maintain a system set up by the Smith regime of collecting waste every day. People care but they have a government that does not care and eventually they too stop caring.”

Chartered Certified Accountant Ishemupenyu Chagonda blames the education system for not inculcating environmental best practice.

Some contributors aver that the developed world learned from plagues the importance of caring for the environment and this has become white culture.

“People need to read about what London was like in the past and how they had to change after plagues. They have seen it all and had to innovate and change,” writes one Gilbert Tigere.

Evans Tongogara chips in: “True. Cities like Chicago [US], if you people follow the history, were a complete disaster. Cattle pens, abattoir waste and raw sewage flowed onto the streets. Information and education and technology were not widely available.”

Award-winning entrepreneur Tsitsi M reiterates the argument that black neighbourhoods are not as well taken care of as others.

“Funny enough on a recent trip to the UK, a friend of mine who recently moved there remarked how she found urban areas that had high ‘Black and Minority Ethnic’ populations ‘dirtier’. This is despite them receiving more or less the same services such as timely refuse collection and water supply, etc.

“I found myself pondering this fact. Are urban blacks less conscious about the environment? Or are there deep-rooted social issues that influence this behaviour.”

Michelle Nonhlanhla Ndebele, former sales manager at Delta Beverages’ Coca-Cola Zimbabwe division disagrees with the argument that it’s a racial issue without a sense of irony.

“I don’t think it’s a race issue,” she writes, “they [developed countries] have a working system compared to most African countries. It’s easier to have garbage put in the right places and have clear waste management systems as opposed to us.”

She says heavy penalties for garbage dumping also make it senseless for white economies to have garbage dumpers.

According to Bere, Harare alone generates between 700 and 900 tonnes of waste every day but the city only has the capacity to collect less than 50% of it.

“In 2021 working with an NGO we helped the city develop a detailed solid waste management strategic plan to solve the problem but up to now no implementation.”

He says if the city council does not take the lead it is difficult for residents to keep a city clean.

Zimbabwe’s Environmental Management Agency (EMA) has a number of laws against littering, which are intended to ensure that all citizens have access to a clean and safe environment but enforcing them is another issue altogether.

The law states that it is illegal to litter on any land, street, or road, except in a designated area or in a container intended for litter.

Fines for littering start at a minimum of US$30, but can increase depending on the circumstances. Businesses in Harare’s central business district can be fined up to US$500 if they don’t have enough litter bins.

Illegal dumping offenders, according to the law, are responsible for removing illegally dumped refuse, or the council will remove it at the offender’s expense.

Public transporters must provide enough waste bins for passengers.

The EMA Act’s Section 70 (1) states that no one can dispose of waste in a way that harms the environment or anyone’s health.

Nevanji Madanhire is an environmental conscious journalist. This is an excerpt from the weekly Newsletter .
Please subscribe for thought provoking fresh insights.

In Conversation With Trevor

In Conversation with Ciaran McSharry

Jamboo Digital Financial Services, founded by two Zimbabweans and London based, aims to service the huge African diaspora in Europe and beyond with ease of remittances and mobile banking. There are over 100 million Africans living outside the continent. Ciaran McSharry, CEO, says the startup will use Zimbabwe as a testing ground for business innovation

Watch his episode here..

Audience Responses

Ciaran McSharry episode, our community had this to say:

@pateltanaka49:

powerful indeed , I’m also a co-founder with a fintech startup here in Zim and yeah the journey hasn’t been easy especially in the early stages where we have to use our own available limited resources, but this also motivated me to keep going and not stop

@anesumudiwa2551:

Thank you , eye opening . all the best to the Jamboo Team

Coming Next: In Conversation with Edith WeUtonga Katiji

Don’t miss the next episode with Singer,President of the Zimbabwe Musicians Union and Vice President of the International Federation of Musicians In Conversation with Trevor.

Podcasts

• Pathisa Nyathi; Zimbabwean Author, Culture and Heritage Expert
• Pete Vowles ; British Ambassador To Zimbabwe
• Dr Olivia Muchena; Zimbabwe Ex-Cabinet Minister